ALIENS WITH DEPORTATION/REMOVAL ORDERS WILL BE REQUIRED TO "SURRENDER" TO INS
by Michael J. Gurfinkel, Esq.

In yet another aftermath of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, the Immigration and Naturalization Service recently published proposed regulations requiring aliens with final removal/deportation orders to surrender to the INS within 30 days of notice, or lose entitlement to many forms of immigration relief and benefits.

The INS has determined that 89 percent of aliens who received final deportation orders, but who are not under detention (in custody), fail to leave the U.S. and/or surrender for deportation when ordered to do so. (Immigration laws generally require the detention and removal of aliens subject to a final order of removal within 90 days of receipt of notice.)

As soon as this proposed rule becomes final, the INS says it will start issuing notices to aliens with final deportation orders, informing them of their duty to surrender to INS, following any final order of expulsion, deportation, or removal, and of the consequences of failing to surrender.

Aliens who were served such "surrender" notices, if they are not yet in custody of the INS, must surrender to the INS within 30 days of the issuance of the notice. The rule applies not only to aliens who are served with Notices to Appear (NTA), but also to aliens who are currently in proceedings, as long as they receive the requisite notice. Here are some questions and answers regarding the new rule:

  1. What is the purpose of the proposed rule?
  2. The purpose of this proposed rule is to establish procedures requiring aliens who have received final orders of removal to surrender to the INS for removal from the United States. The rule establishes procedures for surrender and provides that persons violating those procedures will be denied certain discretionary immigration benefits.

  3. Who will be affected by this rule?
  4. This rule will apply to those aliens who received notice at any point in immigration proceedings of their duty to surrender following any final order of expulsion, deportation, or removal, and of the consequences of failing to surrender. Aliens presently in proceedings will be receiving notice of their duty to surrender once there is a final order of removal. However, the rule may not have retroactive effect on people with old deportation/removal orders, where they have not yet received notice or warnings of the duty to surrender. However, if you have an old deportation order (i.e. an asylum in absentia order), the INS could now send the notice to surrender out to your last address, thereby triggering your obligation to surrender.

  5. How would the rules affect aliens with final removal (deportation) orders?
  6. Aliens who receive the surrender notice, if they are not in the custody of the INS, must surrender within 30 days of the issuance of an administrative order of removal by either an immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals. An alien who has been granted voluntary departure is given an order of removal that automatically becomes administratively final if the alien does not depart under the grant of voluntary departure. If an alien does not voluntarily depart, he or she is also required to surrender to the service.

  7. What are the consequences for an alien who fails to surrender as required?
  8. Those aliens who fail to surrender will be denied discretionary relief from removal, such as asylum, waiver of inadmissibility for criminal convictions, waiver of inadmissibility for fraud, cancellation of removal (suspension of deportation), voluntary departure, adjustment of status, change of status, and registry (or amnesty), at any time while the alien is in the US, and for a period of 10 years after the alien's departure from the US. The alien may also be subject to criminal prosecution.

  9. What effect would an alien's failure to surrender have on motions to reopen or reconsider removal proceedings?

Removal proceedings would not be reopened in the case of an alien who failed to surrender for removal, unless the alien can demonstrate, by clear and convincing evidence, both that the failure to surrender was due to exceptional circumstances, and that he or she actually surrendered for removal as soon as possible after the circumstances that prevented timely surrender had passed.

It is obvious that the INS really means business, and that it intends to go after aliens who are already subject to removal, but who had remained illegally in the country. I would recommend that people who already have received a final order of removal (or deportation), and even those who are currently facing deportation proceedings, to consult with a reputable attorney, who can advise them of their options, or help them obtain legal relief if still possible and available.

It is best to act now, before you receive a "surrender notice" and/or find yourself being awakened in the middle of the night (or early morning) by INS officers out to enforce these removal orders.

 


Back to Main

 
 


© 2000-2007 The Law Offices of Michael J. Gurfinkel, Inc. All rights reserved.
To properly view this site, you must have the latest Flash plug-in. Site design by GALAM arts.